Skip to content
Before I moved to NYC, I had no idea what a speakeasy bar was. My only reference points were TV shows like Brooklyn Nine-Nine and Master of None. But then I stumbled upon a book titled Speakeasy: The Employees Only Guide, and it changed the way I thought about bars, cocktails, and even decision-making.
Because, in a way, choosing a speakeasy is like making any great decision in life—it requires curiosity, exploration, and an ability to navigate hidden opportunities. In fact, research shows that the best decisions often come from those willing to go beyond obvious choices.
Speakeasies originated during the Prohibition Era (1920-1933) when the U.S. government banned alcohol, forcing bars to operate in secrecy. This underground culture shaped modern cocktail bars and the way we experience hidden nightlife today. I covered the full history of speakeasy bars and its impact on drinking culture in my article here.
Also, there’s actually a fascinating psychology behind why we are still drawn to speakeasy bars today. I explored it in this article.
Apotheke
9 Doyers St, New York, NY 10013, USA
Apotheke is situated in the heart of Chinatown. As you walk in the alley, you’ll see a ‘chemist’ sign outside the door.
Apotheke has an in-depth menu including Absinthe-based cocktails.
The bartenders are knowledgeable and give wonderful recommendations based on your palate.
Apotheke doesn’t take reservations, like most of the NYC speakeasy bars.
Attaboy
134 Eldridge St, New York, NY 10002, USA
Attaboy is located in the middle of Eldridge St.
Usually, there is a wait outside the bar, so it can be easily located. However, in case there is no wait, look for a door that says ‘AB’, ring the bell, and wait for someone to answer (pretty cool, eh?).
My favourite part about Attaboy is that they don’t have a set menu. The bartender will ask about your favourite liquor and taste palates (i.e. bitter, fruity, etc). Bartenders craft a drink based on your taste preferences.
My biggest issue with cocktail menus? Too many choices. I’ll overanalyze every option and still second-guess my order. That’s why I love Attaboy, it removes the burden of decision-making by crafting the perfect drink for you, embodying The Paradox of Choice.
Death & Co.
433 E 6th St, New York, NY 10009, USA
Death & Co. has been in NYC for a long time. It also won the ‘Best Cocktail Bar’ award in 2010.
Usually, there is a wait of 45-60 minutes to get inside but it’s definitely worth it.
Whiskey lovers will especially appreciate the menu.
Bo Peep
64 W 36th St, New York, NY 10018, USA
Bo Peep is situated below the Ragtrader bar in midtown Manhattan near Herald Square.
As you reach Ragtrader, you will find a small alleyway with a neon sign pointing downwards. Just walk down the small path and you will find Bo Peep.
It is known for its cocktails, vintage decor, and live piano. I really loved their pizza!
The place is lively and great for dates.
William Barnacle Tavern
80 St Marks Pl, New York, NY 10003, USA
William Barnacle has existed since the prohibition era (which they proudly display at the entrance).
Apparently, a young Frank Sinatra was a waiter at this bar. But I personally couldn’t find any proof.
It is a rare gem in the East Village which is usually empty. I love this bar for the same reason.
It is a rundown theatre that specializes in Absinthe-based cocktails. And when I say specialize, I mean they only serve Absinthe.
William Barnacle Tavern’s menu consists of different types of Absinthe and varying level of preparations – classic Absinthe or Absinthe cocktails.
If you have never tried an Absinthe drink and want to give it a try – William Barnacle Tavern is the place as the bartenders are friendly and knowledgeable.
Pro tip: Ask for Pete at the bar.
For a more comprehensive list, refer to my Google list of Speakeasy in NYC:
Honorary Mentions
- Employees Only – The bar that inspired Speakeasy: The Employees Only Guide.
- Angel’s Share – A hidden Japanese whiskey bar.
- The Garret – A speakeasy above a Five Guys (yes, really).
- Patent Pending – A Nikola Tesla-themed bar inside a coffee shop.
By the way, if you’ve watched Master of None, Aziz Ansari goes to PDT Speakeasy. And if you like Aziz Ansari, here’s my book summary of his book, Modern Romance.
A few things to remember about NYC Speakeasy Bars:
- Be prepared to wait. Speakeasy bars are usually small intimate places which are usually packed at night
- If you don’t understand which cocktail to order from the vast menu, ask the bartender or the server. They are really knowledgeable
- Go with a small group of friends – I cannot emphasize this point enough. Some speakeasy bars will outright decline if you have a group bigger than 5-6 people
- Dress nicely
- Speakeasy bars are somewhat expensive; also, it’s NYC?! Usually, each cocktail will run you up to $20 + in tips
